FOOT HEALTH FORUM Login as administrator
 Subject: RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid
 
Author: Bernie Secoura
Date:   11/5/2004 4:04 pm PDT
DISCLAIMER:
THE FOLLOWING IS OFFERED AS GENERAL INFORMATION ONLY, AND MAY NOT BE APPLICABLE TO THE SPECIFIC QUESTIONER'S PROBLEM. IT IS NOT BASED ON ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE OR EXAMINATION OF THE QUESTIONER AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON AS DEFINITIVE MEDICAL OPINION. ONLY THROUGH HANDS ON PHYSICAL CONTACT WITH PATIENTS CAN ACCURATE MEDICAL ADVICE BE GIVEN. NO DOCTOR/PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IS CREATED OR ESTABLISHED OR MAY BE INFERRED. THE QUESTIONER SHOULD CONTACT HIS OR HER OWN DOCTOR BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH ANY SUGGESTIONS FORTHCOMING HEREIN.

I wasn't intending to challenge you with the word, "bothersome," but employment of ANY elective medical or surgical treatment in the attempt to help or cure a non-life-threatening condition is predicated on how "bothersome" the condition is to the patient. Of course, it's relative . . That's why only YOU can decide when the "bother" of having the symptoms is worth doing something about it.

Now, I don't believe you've ever confirmed it, but I've assume all along that we are talking about the TIBIAL sesamoid. That's the one closer to the mid-line of the body.

It is neither a radical nor an uncommon surgery at all, and if properly performed, inflicting minimal damage to or with adequate repair of the tendon in which the sesamoid is invested, and if the medial structures of the joint are sufficiently reinforced with suturing and the great toe bandaged in an appropriate position for a few weeks, in my experience, I have not seen the undesirable sequelae which you've mentioned.

As far as post-op pain for a period of anything like 15 months, barring something going terribly wrong, I think that terribly unlikely. I would say that, in my hands, most patients are back at a stand up job within 4 weeks or so.

But I'm speaking of a TOTAL sesamoidectomy, as I really don't see the value in a partial sesamoidectomy. First of all, if it is in two pieces . . how does one define the fractured piece? Secondly, it is not a critical structure in the foot which cannot easily be done without.

In the end, the decision is certainly yours and yours alone, and no amount of pressure should be put upon you to make that decision. Again, I say that whether or not you will chose to have the surgery depends entirely on your own judgment as to whether the symptoms warrant that which I personally would consider a relatively small risk. I've never done a procedure on a patient which I would not, under the same circumstances have had perfomed on myself.

Ball's in YOUR court.

Reply To This Message

 Topics Author  Date      
 Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/4/2004 9:28 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/4/2004 4:31 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/5/2004 1:42 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/5/2004 2:34 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/5/2004 3:23 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid    
Bernie Secoura 11/5/2004 4:04 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/8/2004 10:12 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/8/2004 11:37 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/8/2004 12:09 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/8/2004 4:35 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/8/2004 4:42 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Edytha 1/17/2005 12:54 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Deb 3/22/2006 1:13 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
David Zuckerman DPM 11/7/2004 8:54 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/8/2004 12:17 am PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Bernie Secoura 11/8/2004 4:55 pm PDT
 RE: Removing 1/3 of a Tibial Sesamoid   new  
Valerie 11/9/2004 9:13 am PDT
 Reply To This Message
 Your Name:  
 Your Email:  
 Subject:  
  Submission Validation Question: What is 71 + 12? *  
* indicates required field